Our car policy experts weighed a range of factors, including cost, claims satisfaction, fiscal forte, and coverage handiness, to come up with the best car indemnity companies for different types of drivers. quick to shop car policy ? Start calculator Because some companies offer abject rates but have fewer coverage options, while others have bang-up customer service but are more expensive, we recommend thinking about what ’ s most significant to you when shopping for car policy. then, compare quotes from multiple companies to find the best rates and coverage for your needs.

Best for cheap rates: GEICO


4.4 Policygenius denounce How we score : Policygenius ’ ratings are determined by our column team. Our methodology takes multiple factors into score, including price, fiscal ratings, timbre of customer serve, and other product-specific features .GEICO logo One of the most recognizable car policy carriers on the market is besides a dependable go-to for criterion car policy. Pros

  • available countrywide
  • Easy-to-use web site and mobile app
  • enough of discounts
  • Comprehensive customer service
  • Wide array of other coverages, including rideshare insurance and collector ’ randomness insurance


  • average claims satisfaction
  • Middling customer ratings
  • Doesn ’ t underwrite all their other insurance products

Read our full GEICO review Get quotes

Why GEICO is the best car indemnity for cheap rates

Our psychoanalysis found that a full coverage policy with GEICO is 35 % cheaper than average. In fact, GEICO ‘s low rates could save some drivers an average of $ 622 per year on coverage. GEICO ‘s hanker tilt of discounts besides helps make it the best car policy company for cheap rates, particularly since many of these savings are easy for most people to get. Some of GEICO ’ s discounts include savings for taking a defensive force run, owning a brand-new cable car, and insuring multiple vehicles on the same policy .

state handiness

All 50 states and the District of Columbia

Best for customer service : Amica


4.2 Policygenius denounce How we score : Policygenius ’ ratings are determined by our column team. Our methodology takes multiple factors into account, including price, fiscal ratings, quality of customer service, and other product-specific features .Amica logo Amica, while expensive, is a capital option for shoppers interest in top-of-the-line service. Pros

  • Top-rated customer servicing and claims satisfaction
  • premium coverage available
  • variety show of singular perks and features
  • Quick reply times from agents


  • Pricier than competitors
  • Can be finical when it comes to customers
  • not available in Hawaii

Read our full Amica inspection Get quotes

Why Amica is the best car policy for customer overhaul

If customer service is your clear precedence, Amica may be the best ship’s company for you. In 2021, J.D. Power ranked Amica fourth in the state for claims gratification, and it ’ s systematically scored well for customer happiness. Amica is n’t barely the best car policy company for customer serve, it ‘s besides 4 % cheaper than diligence average. however, drivers with an accident or ticket on their record will see importantly higher rates compared to drivers with immaculate records .

express handiness

available in every state and the District of Columbia, with the exception of Hawaii .

Best for adolescent drivers : State farm

State Farm

4 Policygenius rat How we score : Policygenius ’ ratings are determined by our column team. Our methodology takes multiple factors into score, including pricing, fiscal ratings, timbre of customer service, and other product-specific features .State Farm logo With above-average claims gratification, a rate of discounts, and great options for adolescent drivers, it makes sense that State Farm is the largest car insurance company in the U.S. Pros

  • available nationally
  • plan to help young drivers save money
  • Above-average claims satisfaction ratings


  • No peculiarity coverage options
  • Pricier than like competitors

Read our full State Farm review Get quotes

Why State Farm is the best car insurance for teenage drivers

typically, adolescent drivers pay much more for car policy than drivers with more experience behind the wheel. A 16-year-old pays an average of 255 % more for indemnity than the typical adult — but our analysis found that State Farm is a much cheaper choice for young drivers. In fact, State Farm charges adolescent drivers who have their own policy about $ 2,000 less for coverage than industry average for the like long time group. submit Farm besides offers ways to offset the price of adding a adolescent driver to an car policy policy, like its Steer Clear program for drivers under 25, which tracks driving behavior through an app that besides includes informational quizzes and videos .

state handiness 

All 50 states and the District of Columbia .

Best for coverage options : Safeco


3.6 Policygenius evaluation How we score : Policygenius ’ ratings are determined by our editorial team. Our methodology takes multiple factors into account, including price, fiscal ratings, quality of customer overhaul, and early product-specific features .Safeco logo Safeco offers four alone policy tiers so you can find the accurate level of coverage that ’ s right for you. just keep in mind it doesn ’ t have the best customer overhaul ratings. Pros

  • Offers equipment breakdown coverage to replace bankrupt appliances for just $ 2 a calendar month
  • File claims on-line or over the call
  • Get property damage claims estimates through video recording chat


  • Rates are 35 % higher than the home average — approximately $ 1,683 per year
  • Less-than-stellar customer service ratings
  • No unique discounts for green or tech-savvy homes

Read our full Safeco reappraisal Get quotes

Why Safeco is the best car insurance for coverage options

Safeco is the best cable car indemnity company for people who want to get the most out of their car coverage. Besides offering a fully rate of standard coverage options, Safeco besides offers some extra forms of coverage and perks that you might not find at other car insurance companies, including :

  • Diminishing deductible : For every year of safe force, your deductible will drop by $ 100, up to $ 500 sum .
  • New car refilling : Pays to replace your cable car with a brand-new model if your fomite is less than one year old when it ‘s totaled .
  • rental cable car reimbursement : Pays for the price of a rental cable car if yours is in the denounce after a brood accident .
  • wayside aid : Covers the monetary value of aid or towing if you ’ re stranded on the side of the road because of a flat tire, dead battery, empty gas tank, an accidental lockout, and more .
  • original parts successor : Pays to replace your car ‘s damaged parts with high-quality manufacturer parts, or comparable parts if the originals are n’t available .

state handiness

All 50 states and the District of Columbia

Best for military families : USAA


4.3 Policygenius rate How we score : Policygenius ’ ratings are determined by our editorial team. Our methodology takes multiple factors into score, including price, fiscal ratings, quality of customer service, and other product-specific features .USAA  logo USAA is a solid choice for military families looking for both homeowners insurance and a new home security system — its partnership with ADT means you ’ ll spare on both. But watch out for higher-than-average premiums. Pros

  • grudge discounts for nothing claims, being a loyal USAA member, opting into e-billing, and more
  • Offers earthquake coverage — which is unvoiced to come by
  • Get discounted home security systems and a discount on premiums through its partnership with ADT


  • Rates are 69 % higher than the national average — roughly $ 2,112 per year
  • Doesn ’ thymine propose extended or guaranteed substitution cost populate coverage
  • entirely available to military families

Read our full USAA inspection Get quotes

Why USAA is the best car indemnity for military families

Unlike early policy companies, USAA is entirely available to active and withdraw members of the military and their families. But if you ‘re eligible for coverage, you could get the best rates about. Our analysis found that a full coverage policy with USAA is 37 % cheaper than average, meaning big savings. In addition to low rates, USAA is besides known for leading customer service and high claims satisfaction. In fact J.D. Power ranked it beginning in its 2021 review of overall customer claims gratification .

state handiness 

All 50 states and the District of Columbia .

Best smaller car policy company : erie


Erie logo A regional aircraft carrier with standout claims satisfaction ratings, Erie ’ s independent drawback is that it ’ second simply not available in many states. Pros

  • Standout customer service
  • premium coverage options
  • Well-designed, streamlined web site
  • Accident forgiveness is offered as a loyalty perk up


  • not available in most states
  • May shed you if you have multiple accidents or moving violations
  • No Erie mobile app

Get quotes

Why Erie is the best smaller car insurance company 

Erie is n’t available everywhere, but if you live in one of the 12 states where it ’ s offered, it ’ s a great choice for coverage with a reputation for ace customer avail. It ’ south besides a adept consider — our analysis found that A full-coverage policy with Erie costs 36 % less than industry modal, meaning it ’ s cheaper than a lot of bigger companies. It may not be a national carrier, but Erie offers all the perks of a major insurance company. Erie customers can choose from plenty of coverage options, like raw car successor, rental reimbursement, and wayside aid .

state handiness

available in the District of Columbia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, and Wisconsin.


Root logo Root offers shoppers the luck to pay their rates based on driving behavior while tracked by a mobile app, but lacks the coverage options and features of more established carriers. Pros

  • Everything can be done through the app
  • price is based on driving habits
  • Roadside aid included with every policy


  • App track may lead to privacy concerns
  • Fewer coverage options than competitors
  • not available in every express

Get quotes

Why Root is the best car insurance for mobile app and digital tools

A relative newcomer to the car indemnity industry, Root sets rates based on driving demeanor rather of the common factors like your localization or age. root tracks your driving habits with a mobile app and calculates your rates based on a test menstruation. We found that safe drivers could pay 63 % less for full coverage with Root compared to diligence average. Root besides allows drivers to manage their policies, pay their premiums, and file and monitor claims through its mobile app, which earned good reviews on both the Google Play storehouse and App Store .

state handiness 

available in Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Mexico, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, West Virginia, and Wisconsin .

number of the acme car insurance companies

Our top picks are standouts, but there are early great, low-cost cable car indemnity options that may be the best choice for some drivers. Check out our prolong tilt of the best car indemnity companies of 2022 .

company median annual premiums J.D. Power score
MAPFRE $1,040 844
USAA $1,048 890
Auto-Owners Insurance $1,070 890
Erie $1,139 880
GEICO $1,187 871
American Family $1,227 862
State Farm $1,383 881
Nationwide $1,463 876
NJ Manufacturers $1,481 909
COUNTRY Financial $1,543 863
Travelers $1,580 861
Amica $1,687 907
Progressive $1,758 856
National General $1,819 815
Farmers $1,934 872
The Hartford $1,939 888
Allstate $1,974 876
CSAA $2,318 862
MetLife $2,431 886
Mercury Insurance $2,554 849

Policygenius analysis of rates provided by Quadrant Information Services. Rates provided are a sample of costs. Your actual quotes may differ.

What are the different types of car insurance?

All of our picks for the top car indemnity companies have the basic coverage that every driver needs in order to be amply protected. It ’ s a good theme to get familiar with the unlike types of car indemnity coverage before you shop for policy, so you know precisely what ’ sulfur going into your policy .

Coverage type What it does
Property damage liability Covers the cost of the other party’s repairs if you’re at-fault in a car accident
Bodily injury liability Pays for the other party’s medical bills and related expenses if you cause an accident
Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage Covers the costs if you’re hit by a driver without insurance, or who doesn’t have enough insurance to pay for the damage
Collision coverage Pays for damage to your own car after an accident, even if you were the one at-fault
Comprehensive coverage Covers damage to your car not caused by a collision, like damage from extreme weather, fire or theft
Personal injury protection Required in no-fault states, pays for your own medical expenses after an accident
MedPay Available in at-fault states, pays for medical bills after an accident, usually up to a limited amount

→ Learn more about the different types of car insurance coverage

Choosing the best car insurance company

Policygenius makes it easy to choose the best cable car policy company, because we show you quotes from the exceed companies and help you choose the policy that ’ s best for you. Whether you ’ re looking for a caller with white baseball glove service or you want the most low-cost choice out there, here ’ s what every driver should look for .

Here’s what to consider when you’re comparing car insurance policies:

  1. Customer service and claims handling. Policygenius has detailed company review of top car indemnity carriers, so read up on how some of the best providers fare on customer serve and claims gratification .
  2. price. Policygenius can help you compare quotes from top companies, so you can see which one offers you the best coverage at the best price. Remember to make certain you ’ re comparing apples to apples — one party may offer you a 6-month policy for $ 750 and another may offer you a yearlong one for $ 900, so take a expect at the specifics before you choose your coverage .
  3. extra coverage options. While most car policy companies offer the same rate of standard car indemnity options that make up a wax coverage policy, some offer a across-the-board range of coverage options than others, including coverage for things like personal belongings stolen from your cable car, or extra coverage if your pets are injured in an accident. You should besides check to see which early insurance products are on offer – you can ’ metric ton bundle your car and home indemnity with a company that only offers car policies .
  4. Discounts and savings opportunities. The best car indemnity companies can offset the cost of your premiums by offering discounts on car policy for things like safe drive, bundling your car and home indemnity, paying your bill in wide at the begin of the year, or taking a defensive drive course .

→ Learn more about how to buy car policy

What car insurance discounts are available?

The best car indemnity companies will all offer a wide range of discounts that can help you find your best rates. Some of the most common car indemnity discounts include :

  • Multi-policy discount : For bundling your car insurance with home plate or renters coverage from the like company
  • Multi-car rebate : For insuring more than one fomite on the lapp car insurance policy
  • Claims-free rebate : For drivers with no late claims on their record
  • scholar dismiss : For young drivers who maintain above a certain GPA in school
  • Telematics program : Savings in exchange for safe drive, normally tracked through a smartphone app or circuit board device
  • defensive force course for 55+ : For older drivers who complete a defensive drive class
  • Paying in fully upfront discount rate : For drivers who pay their full annual agio at the start of the policy term

Frequently asked questions

Are there different types of car insurance companies?

Yes — some car policy companies are smaller, regional carriers that alone offer coverage in a few states, while others are national companies that offer policies no topic where you are in the U.S. Some companies lone offer car policy, while others can besides insure your home, gravy boat, RV or trailer .

How do I find the best car insurance rates?

The most surefire way to get the best car insurance rates is to shop around, and compare quotes from at least three different companies before you choose coverage. Policygenius can help you see quotes from top companies in one survive, therefore you know you ’ re choosing the best price.

Can anyone get USAA car insurance?

No, USAA insurance is limited to current and former members of the U.S. military, arsenic well as their spouses and children. If that doesn ’ metric ton identify you, you ’ ll have to look for car policy coverage elsewhere .

How do I find the best discounts?

Discounts will be automatically applied to your policy when you buy insurance, but to make surely you ’ re getting all the best savings, ask about specific discounts during the car insurance application work. Savings for bundling policies and insuring multiple cars can typically net you bigger savings than discounts for vehicle features .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *